In November, I went to Huế to give a talk to physics students who are in a mirror program with the best university in the world. I am, of course, talking about the University of Virginia. It doesn’t matter how long it’s been since I graduated from the school or how little I’ve contributed to any of the school’s funds, I love UVa and proclaim it pretty much any opportunity I have.
To be offered the opportunity to sing the praises of UVa and the Physic Department, as official business, well that’s an opportunity too excellent to resist. My talk was not so blatantly rah-rah UVa, but more along the lines of my life experiences that brought me to be talking to the 40 or so students gathered around that afternoon. The theme of my talk was that getting an education in physics is one step toward having a career outside the box.
I was not surprised that no one had heard about the “box” in Vietnam. I actually planned on this and gave them concrete examples of what the Vietnamese student “box” is. The box confines students to want to work in a bank or be a manager in a company after they have studied business administration, finance, or accounting. The stereo type of “Asians” studying in the U.S. is that they study engineering, right? The graduate engineering and science schools are filled with them. But as soon as you start looking at where those Asians come from, you find they’re mainly Chinese or Korean. The Vietnamese are in the MBA programs as far as I can tell.
As with all generalizations, there are always exceptions to the rule. That goes without saying. But when you’re trying to define what the “box” is to a group of young students, making light of the fact that all their peers are looking to study business to do business is the best way to turn our overused metaphor (is it a cliche?) into something they could actually use.
I was surprised that when I went out with a few of them for dinner that night, that the “outside the box” thinking is what stuck with them the most. No, I’m not narcissistic to be sad that they didn’t say my life was the most interesting part of the talk, but I didn’t realize that would be the part they would joke about later on.
Overall, the talk was fun. As much as I try to encourage audience participation, there were only a few people who raised their hands to speak when I asked questions or asked for comments. Later the professor who helped organize the event said “We have the same problem when the visiting professors come. The first week they’re very quiet, the second week they’re not so shy, and by the third week, you can’t shut them up.” Based on his assessment of the students, I should feel happy that I got any response on day one.
I talked about the student visa process, what a visa really is, and about some scholarship opportunities through the Embassy (Fulbright) and through the university (fellowships).
Aside from the talk with the students, which really was the highlight of the trip, I had some other related work that had me run around the city. My impression of the city is that while it is scenic, it is depressed. Vinh City in Nghe An province may not be a tourist destination, but at least there are car and motorbike dealerships all over the place. There is obviously money flowing into the town.
Hue on the other hand, looks stagnant. Even the taxi driver we had said there were no big companies or factories near by to employ people. Tourists would come for a day or two, then keep going to Da nang or Hoi An. They would tour the tombs, but not really spend much money in the city.
You could see the taxi driver’s commentary backed up by the small shops and businesses that lined the streets. There were no big-name shops, there weren’t really any big shops at all. There were some places to buy motorbikes, but there weren’t any obvious car dealerships. Traffic in general was not a problem. At rush hour, there were lots of cars on the scenic bridges connecting the two sides of the city, but this was not Hanoi or HCMC.
What stood out in my mind was the hospital that we visited. It is a huge facility in the middle of the city that has been supported by Japanese and U.S. donations. There is a cardiac wing, a general ward, a ward for pregnant mothers, and has a full range of imaging modalities. Basically, the doctors there said if you get hurt anywhere in the middle of the country, you’re going to wind up at that hospital. It’s the best. It’s probably better than most of the hospitals in Hanoi. So, if there is any place to get hurt in Vietnam, it’s in Hue.
Although you would think that a large hospital like this would be an anchor for jobs and businesses in the area, the problem is that the jobs are mostly government jobs on low salaries. So, it’s not quite the same as a hospital in the US that would have well-paid doctors and administrators who sink money back into the local economy. Although doctors wind up getting paid in Vietnam, it’s not based on their salary, it’s based on the inducements required to facilitate expedient service (aka: no money, no treatment).
I’ll finish by saying that I thoroughly enjoyed being in Hue. The city sits along a beautiful bend in the Perfume River, has a number of neat hotels that overlook the old citadel, and has some good food if you know where to find it. That said, there is a poverty that lies beneath the surface of the nicer looking tourist areas. Don’t be fooled, but enjoy nonetheless.


























